This CrankCentralStation piece by James Miller on the mass production of embryos has plenty of funnies. This, however, is particularly hilarious:
Embryo selection gets even more interesting when we consider how a nation such as China might use it. Imagine that in ten years China forces all its college students to get genetic tests. Students with intelligence genes in the top 1% of the top 1% of humankind are then forced to donate sperm or eggs.
See, this is what I don’t understand about the sort of “libertarians” who write at TCS. They scream like freshly-neutered puppies if anyone tries to raise their taxes, but they have zero problem with having the government force people to donate their sperm and eggs to create an army of hyper-intelligent Over Men:
China then uses the sperm and eggs to create a billion embryos each year. The genetic intellectual potential of all these embryos is checked. Those in the top 10,000 are implanted into women.
How are you likin’ this Brave New World, ladies? Are you looking forward to being used as the government’s incubators for its Übermensches?
Each of these embryos has the intellectual potential to be in the top one-billionth of humankind. Now because of environmental factors many of these embryos won’t turn into intellectual titans.
And I’m sure they’ll lead rich and fulfilling lives as failed genetic experiments.
But let’s say that one in ten does. This means that each year 1,000 people with the scientific ability of Einstein will be born. By 2035 they will become adults and start doing scientific research. I imagine these Einsteins will be rather helpful to China’s economy and military.
“Mr. President, we must not allow a Chinese-super-baby gap!”
Get outta here, ya maniac!
UPDATE: Someone who knows something about genetics replies to Miller in the comments. I will imagine Dr. Miller’s responses:
Ten years from now?…the Chinese are going to screen 1 billion 3-day old embryoes looking for the 10,000 best?
“Each of these embryos has the intellectual potential to be in the top one-billionth of humankind.” What? Each of these would be among the “top six or seven” smartest people on Earth? And now there are going to be 10,000 of those born each year? Starting ten years from now?
Is it really that simple? We can’t do any of this…none of the techniques we are using today would ever be used to do this. But even if any of this could work (and it can’t) we might be able to do such a thing once or twice…One billion times? with the current technology? ten years from now? in China? Really?
Imagined Miller response: You are clearly the victim of linear thinking, my friend. Once the Singularity arrives, all technological progress will increase exponentially forever and ever. Thus, the Chinese will be able to screen 10,000 embryos per day if they’re lazy. The real number of post-singularity embryos screened could reach 20 kajillion-katrillion.
Do you have any idea how expensive that would be (the first time) if we are ever able to do it? Who is going to fund the project to develop this technology?
Imagined Miller response: Tax cuts!
And then provide the service as a commodity? Our global economy would need to be fundamentally different long before this could happen. No corporate entity would undertake it…no government.
Imagined Miller response: The Laffer curve states that if you cut taxes to a rate of -25% for the richest individuals, then revenue will go up forever.
What are you thinking? Are you even thinking at all when you write such foolishness?
Imagined Miller response: Uh… do I have to answer that?