Richard Brookhiser is one of the few — well, okay — the only smart polyp in the Cornhole. Yeah, I know: Sharing a forum with Jonah Goldberg can make even John Podhoretz look smart, but you know what I mean. Brookhiser isn’t a troglodyte. While he is certainly a wingnut (witness, if you ever saw the History Channel’s The Presidents series, Brookhiser’s enthusiatic, fawning endorsement of Theodore Roosevelt’s “Kill Em All” foriegn policy as juxtaposed to his coolly deprecating assessment of TR’s relatively decent domestic quasi-progressivism), his wingnuttery often has a placidity to it.
But that doesn’t mean it’s subtle. Once again overcome with the urge to laud a dead wingnut saint, Brookhiser once again lets hagiographical enthusiasm override judgment:
Hamilton, Right Again [Rick Brookhiser]
Alexander Hamilton’s northern Manhattan summer house, the Grange, built in 1802 two years before he was killed, is about to be moved to a new location at W. 141st St. and Hamilton Terrace[…]But this was the detail that caught my eye from this morning’s NYTimes (p. B5): “Insights have also been gleaned from what the architects did not find, like evidence of a dumbwaiter that was once supposed to have existed. Mr. Waite [the architect] interpreted this as a sign that much of the Hamiltons’ family life took place downstairs, close to the kitchen. “This house was built to be operated without slaves,” he said.
C’mon, Rick. Fine, so Hamilton was maybe against slavery in the abstract. But the absence (or presence) of a dumbwaiter in Hamilton’s home is the silliest thing one could present as evidence of such a position.
Quick: Who is credited with inventing the dumbwaiter, and installed them everywhere he could? I’ll provide three hints: He was a redhead from Virginia, and owned slaves (even going so far as to sleep with one slave who happened to be his dead wife’s half-sister), who yet excoriated slavery as an institution.
Read the rest of this entry »






