Posted on July 20th, 2008 by Gavin M.
The corrections have been coming in after the entire right-blogosphere swallowed a phony story that the American Physical Society had changed its position on global warming. Ace of Spades HQ got in early (and they hate us a lot), so let’s visit them first:
Internal Disagreement at APS
—Gabriel Malor
Or, in other words, “External Disagreement About APS.” Titles are crucial; get a good title and you’re halfway there. Another one might be, “Who Can Say For Sure That There Isn’t Some Internal Disagreement at APS,” or possibly, “Are You There, God? It’s Me, Malor.”
On Thursday, I told you about the American Physical Society’s new-found recognition that there is a “considerable presence” of skepticism within the scientific community of anthropogenic global warming. (A day earlier than most other political blogs noticed, I might add; AOSHQ: where you either get the news first or months late!) APS is now presenting articles in its magazine and on its website which debate the question. But it turns out that APS is not quite ready to admit that the global warming consensus is crumbling.
In other words, a single newsletter by one of 39 subgroups of the APS featured ‘articles which debate the question,’ with a big disclaimer in red text at the top of the page — while the position of the APS has not changed even one tiny bit. In related news, it turns out that NASA is not quite ready to admit that the moon is made of cheese.
In just two days this thing has turned into an embarrassment for just about everyone.
That’s what I’m going to say the next time I’m walking down the street and slip in some poo and then wear it on my pants for two days. I’ll stand up and explain, “All this slipping in poo by just about everyone has really made a mess of just about everyone’s pants.”
See, that’s a sneaky way of spreading blame around without anyone knowing that it’s really you who are quote-unquote “to blame!” It’s like that poem:
This Is Just To Say
Just about everyone has eaten
the plums
that were in
the icebox
and which
you were probably
saving
for breakfast.
Forgive just about everyone
they were delicious
so sweet
and so cold.
APS has “reaffirmed” its position on anthropogenic global warming;
Moreover, APS has “reaffirmed” its “position” on anthropogenic so-called “global warming.”
it turns out that the Physics and Society magazine and online forum is the only component that wants to have this debate.
I.e., when he originally linked to the Forum on Physics and Society, he didn’t even know what he was linking to.
APS’s controlling body is taking action to straighten things out. As a result, I’d say the organization as a whole is about to lose some credibility:
Wow. Just wow.
What follows is a rapidly ginned-up controversy in which Lord Monckton, the wingnut and imposter (Monckton falsely claims to have shared the Nobel Prize with Al Gore, and to be a member of Parliament) who authored the disclaimed, red-texted paper, and (get this) who apparently fed the fake story to DailyTech in the first place, complains that he was treated unfairly. We also find Monckton cc-ing emails to Jonah Goldberg.*
Yes indeed, someone is about to lose some credibility. But as the wingnuts know, if they howl and carry on with enough wounded abjection, some observers will think that the loser in this affair is the American Physical Society.
Tim Lambert at Deltoid has some details on Monckton’s paper, and on the op-ed in The Australian that Mallor cited as his other piece of evidence that, in his words, the ‘global warming hoax is slowly coming apart.’ For more context, here’s our original Shorter, with cites and links.
Initial whoopsie! score: 6 out of 10.
Adjustments: +2 for zeal and boasting.
Punk-out score: 8 out of 10.
Adjustments: -1 because Monckton is providing effective smoke screen.
Total: 7.5 out of 10.
Next customer: Glenn “Instapundit” Reynolds.
Update: It would only be right to assist in the burdens of our right-wing colleagues, so instead of just pointing and laughing like lesser souls might do, we will also help supply them with appropriate corrections.
Ace of Spades HQ:
[ahem]
“Regarding the story, “Blar-har-har! The Wheels Are Coming Off The Global-Warming Fraudmobile” in our edition of 7/16/08, we were too eager to credit a story that the APS has changed its position on bla-bla, and whatever it said, and we will be more careful to evaluate such claims in the future — especially when they originate with the titanically crapulent Christopher “The Duke and/or Dauphin” Monckton or Michael “The Trasher” Asher, who have burned us once and shall not burn us again. We are sorry for the etc., kthxbai. >^..^< "
They can use that if they want to, but they can't change the 'kthxbai' or the emoticon kitty.
* Correction: The email came from the anti-environmental activist Benny Peiser.