First it was twelve year old boys, and now it’s injured Iraqi war vets:
How does one decipher whether a person is truly mentally ill, or is exploiting their battle experiences to their fullest advantage?
How do we know if Troy is the person he is because of the battlefield experiences, or if he is choosing to be this person because others are enabling him? Since we’re not hearing from Troy’s pre-war family and friends it is difficult to really know what he was life prior to his tour in Iraq.
I’m very skeptical of Troy’s “problems” and so should others who read this article.
He is capable of rational thought and he is making choices. He choses to swallow pills and watch TV in the dark- to shut himself in…to refuse medical/psych care and, I really wonder- the required services that would make him a better person.
When we enable some people to be the worst they can be, they take advantage and do just that.
Of course, when you read the article, it’s hard to see how someone could come to the conclusion that this vet is faking illness:
Troy’s problems started after his tour. While he was on home leave from Fort Stewart one weekend, Michelle found him sitting on the bed with a bottle of pills. He said he couldn’t go back. Michelle drove him to the Martinsburg VA hospital, which shipped him to Walter Reed for three weeks of psychiatric care.
He was sent back to Fort Stewart and returned to duty, a reality he could not cope with. Twice he tried to commit suicide and was hospitalized at Winn Army Community Hospital before being medically discharged for PTSD in 2004. After 13 years in uniform, Troy got nearly the lowest disability rating possible, a $11,349 severance check and no benefits.
You know, I’ve had jobs I’ve hated before. I mean really, really hated. And I have taken mental health days by calling in sick once or twice in my life. But I can’t recall ever attempting suicide in an effort to get out of going to work. Perhaps in Raven’s world, this is a sign of a malingerer. But when normal people hear a story like this, their first thought isn’t “ooh, what a faker!”; their first thought is “this is a man who is really suffering”.
I love this new version of conservatism. There is nothing too base, too venal, too cold-blooded for them to say. There is no one they won’t smear, no reputation they won’t seek to tarnish, no depth to which they will not sink in order to destroy anything that interferes with their pet narratives about how they think the world works, whether it be ‘government insurance is socialism’ or ‘the Iraq war is a war for civilization and therefore worth any sacrifice (as long as it’s not mine).’ Anything — absolutely anything at all — is acceptable, except for even the barest hint of the thought that they might actually be wrong about something in even the slightest measure.
The only good thing for us is that, as reality becomes ever more obviously divergent from the bizarre pictures of it painted in the minds of people like this, the ranting that comes from them becomes ever more obviously foul and disgusting. It showed in the howling brigades’ smears of Graeme Frost, and it shows here. There is hope that, if most people really are not baying monsters at heart, but decent individuals, the increasing levels of bile coming from those who actually are baying monsters will start to drive the decent people away from them.
In the last week, they’ve stalked a twelve year old with disabilities and called an Iraqi war vet with brain injuries a malingerer. I’m holding out for the trifecta: these guys don’t support the war. Any chance one of you might want to go kick one of them in the face? Be sure to get pictures, so we can all see how brave and patriotic you are.
Update:
Jesus Christ. Raven has taken issue with my characterization of her as a “baying monster,” and has linked to other posts she’s written to demonstrate her infinite compassion for our veterans. Upon reading another account of a soldier who ended up on total disability from post-traumatic stress disorder, her truly bodhisattva-like compassion motived her to say:
You know, when I read lines like this, I lose respect and sympathy…does that make me cruel or cold? I don’t think so. Mr. Awad [the disabled soldier] should realize he is lucky to be alive. He should visit with some of my patients- who are alive, but who have lost it all.
Well. How could I ever have questioned the deeply caring nature of this person? Truly, the shame is mine.
Clif adds:
Kender, a commenter over at Raven’s nest, kicks it up a notch:
The liberal mindset is what causes PTSD. Boys being raised to men without a strong male role model, and having a false sense of what life is about is causing our young men to go to war and come home freaked out.
To which the compassionate Raven squawks:
Kender, there is a lot of truth to what you’ve said.
When we consider that the past wars were much gorier and bloodier. My own father saw a lot of gore; he lost many friends. Yet he managed to move on without letting it get to him; he chose to live his life as he wanted and not to succumb to his ghosts, as I call them.
The men of the past are a lost breed.
Words fail me.
Gavin adds:
Apparently, Raven is trying to ‘win’ the debate by deleting comments unfavorable to her position. Why do people do that?