Shorter Ole Perfesser: I can and will shamelessly blame liberals for everything bad everywhere in the world.
Longer version:
In his latest column — link here for Times $elect subscribers — Paul Krugman complains about the cult of “authenticity” in politics, and how it makes people like John Edwards come across as phonies. FDR was a rich guy who cared about the poor, he says, so why can’t John Edwards be?
Well, John Edwards is no FDR. But the answer to Krugman’s complaint is found in the post 1960s political zeitgeist. Back before identity politics, and the notion that “the personal is political,” the idea of a rich guy representing poor people was entirely plausible. He could be rich, but still have ideas about poverty, and care about them. But now that we have identity politics and the like, that’s impossible: If only a woman can represent women, only a black person can represent blacks, etc. — Barbara Boxer even suggested that Condi Rice couldn’t understand mothers because she was childless — then obviously only a poor person can represent poor people. And since there are no poor people in American political office, poor people perforce go unrepresented. Thus, the “progressive” causes of identity politics and personalization mean that the progressives’ key clients can’t get “authentic” representation. This is probably bad for the country, but it’s certainly a bed that the progressives have made for themselves.
But, but, but, Perfesser! The whole point of Krugman’s excellent and super-awesome column is that:
a.) Republicans such as Fred Thompson and George W. Bush go out of their way to make themselves look like salt-of-the-earth blue-collar types.
-and-
b.) That our pathetic and stupid “press corps” all too often takes the bait.
Our “press corps” mostly shuns doing stories on policy and issues, preferring to instead pen fluffy “personality” pieces on how much “fun” or “likable” or “genuine” candidates are. Just look at this lovely piece by your pal DoughBob LoadPants, who comes out and says (and I happen to agree with him on in part) that American voters are dumb as rocks:
Interestingly, the GOP has a significant likability advantage (and disadvantages almost everywhere else). John McCain may be unpopular with much of the Republican base, but Americans would love to go to the pub with him. Rudy Giuliani, too, seems like a good guy with whom to watch a baseball game at the bar. The super-polished Mitt Romney’s a tougher call, and Duncan Hunter would be a pain because he’d keep asking the immigration status of the busboys.
But the GOP front-runners (save perhaps Newt Gingrich) all have the advantage over Hillary. She may have star power, but you get the sense that most Americans would like to have their picture taken with her and then drink alone. With the exception of Sen. Christopher Dodd, I’d guess all of the Democratic wannabes are more likable than Clinton, too. Sexism probably is part of the equation, but not as much as Clinton’s defenders will claim. There’s room for perceptions to change as we get to know the candidates (though we already know Hillary pretty well).
Please don’t be scandalized by all of this. It’s just something to think about. For the record, I think everyone should vote based on principle. But principles are for a person; they’re less helpful when it comes to predicting people.
If voters actually choose candidates based on how much they’d like to watch a baseball game with- and from conversations I’ve had with many voters, I have no doubt that this is the case- then they are utter, irredeemable morons.
However, I think much of the problem is the that people simply aren’t given the information they need to make intelligent decisions, which is largely the fault of our celebrity “press corps” who more and more resemble New York Post gossip columnists than smart people who give the public essential information. The embarrassing national dumbness of our celebrity press corps hasn’t gotten any better over the years. And if the early coverage of Fred “I’m-a-genuine-good-ol’-boy” Thompson is any indication, it could get a whole lot worse.